Cheaters deleted and banned, problems fixed

Alan VanCouvering recently posted this on the EverQuestLive.com website: Cheaters and the recent up swell of concern (12-8-03) Over the last few days there has been a growing community concern about possible cheating, exploiting and platinum duplication. Rumors and speculation have begun to run rampant, and I've received a lot of concerned email on the topic. First of all, I want to thank you for your concern. The fact that you worry about this stuff as much as we do makes me feel good about the community that I work for. I want to especially thank those that have sent in detailed information about what they thought might be dupe or exploit situations. That information has been very helpful. With your help, we have been able to discover and eliminate some unusual ways of cheating. Obviously I can't go into detail about exactly how this cheating was done. I can tell you that several of our programmers and designers took lengthy breaks from working on their current tasks to define, investigate and smash those exploits. Most of these methods for cheating have been removed. The few that remain will be fixed shortly. We will be watching, and anyone using them will be banned. At the same time, our Customer Service folks have been diligently tracking down the cheaters. We have banned accounts and deleted characters in the hundreds. It's never a good thing to be forced to remove so many accounts, and we're not happy that such cheating was possible. We are pleased, however, to let you know that we are confident that we have located the majority of those that exploited the game and have removed their characters or accounts. Obviously we won't be able to prevent all of the possible ways to cheat. The folks that insist on trying to cheat have proven to be persistent and clever (and here is where I wonder why they don't apply that energy and skill to something beneficial...). We need your help to locate these issues. The multitude of eyes and ears of our players is always the best source of information for us. If you ever suspect that you have discovered something that seems like an exploit, please send that information to us through the Developer's Corner AND through /bug. Please don't assume we have heard the information already. We'd rather have ten reports about something like this than none. I'd also like to address a rumor about the nature of some of the cheating that people have been talking about. There has been speculation in the community that in order to pull off some of the rumored exploits someone had to be working on the "inside". We take such possibilities very seriously. And we have investigated this very thoroughly. We keep track of all special EverQuest commands issued. We have looked into the possibility that someone working here had a hand in helping others cheat, and we have discovered no evidence that indicates that to be the case. Also, the nature of the cheat did not require such inside help. I can't describe the cheat method in any detail, but there was an experience cheat that allowed extremely fast leveling. This required some rather sophisticated cheating, but was being done without inside help. Obviously we have removed that exploit and banned any accounts that used it. Thank you for playing EverQuest. And thank you for you help making the game fun. Have a great holiday season. Alan

Comments

« Previous 1 2 3
Post Comment
Gaming for profit
# Feb 11 2004 at 5:18 PM Rating: Decent
Several posts have been made along the same theme. Cheats, PLing, twinks, selling plat etc for RL money. Many are missing the point. One said they won't stop it until they put them in jail. First off none of this is illegal, only against SOE policy. They therefore can't charge them with anything. The agreement we click on allows SoE to ban or suspend people for breaking these rules. That's it period. Hacking can possibally be termed illegal if it is actual hacking and not taking advantage of mis-programing and hence subject to legal action but even selling accounts, which I have never done, is not only not illegal but probabally not even banable if someone wanted to fight it in court. I have 4 accounts and can, if I feel awake enough, play all 4 at a time. I usually don't as its to tireing. Basically it boils down to, enjoy the game for what you want and don't worry about what others can or can't do. Put pressure on SoE to get rid of the macros that allow people to purchase lower priced items while they are not even at the computer. And for them to continually monitor /bug and other cheat possibilities sent to them.
Gaming for Profit
# Jan 11 2004 at 11:01 PM Rating: Default
Power leveling, exploitation, plat duplicating? Have you gone on any of the auction websites lately? There are characters who users have worked endless hours on and paid their monthly fees to Sony and auctioning their high level characters to others for extra cash. Is this illegal? Bannable? Are users cheating if they sell a character they worked to level? What about the buyers? Are they infringing upon Sony's EULA if they 1. Purchase a character or 2. Purchase an account? Sony could stand to profit from this in additional accounts being applied for. On the other hand, I am a level 62 warrior on the Xev server and I'd hate to rely on a 60 + cleric who was purchased at an auction to keep me alive. Especially if the buyer was new to the game and didnt' know their character. I'd like to hear Sony's opinion on this one myself. What about selling one's account? Sony, what is your opinion?
Cheating
# Dec 18 2003 at 7:19 AM Rating: Default
I seen lots of complaining about cheating and people buying plats online. But there is one thing you all have overlooked. this stuff didn't come from low level chars. In the bazaar the most expensive and best stuff isn't being looted by level 30 40 or 50. It is coming from high level char. I have seen people trying to sale EQ stuff for real money on website. Not one or two items but lots of them.
As for plats being sold on website to cheaters, not all this stuff is macroed (IMHO). Alot of it is from players who have taken their quest to make plat to the next level. They hire their service to companies that sell plat. EQ is now not a game but a way to make money in real life. These people now don't just farm things to make Plat in the bazaar, they take that Plat and turn it into real money and try to recruit other players so they can increase their total plat farming. The more plats you farm the more real money you make.
I seen almost everyone say that it was good that the people who bought plats, who hacked the game, etc were banned. But you missed the most important issue. This is like sending everyone who ever bought drugs to jail for the rest of their life, and giving your blessings to those drug dealers that sold it to them in the first place. If people are farming plats to sell to others players or selling EQ items, accounts, etc. They are more guilty than the ones buying this stuff. Everquest is no longer a game, it has become a real life community with all the real social problems from real life. You have people who are saints always trying to help others, to those who will do anything to get ahead in the game, to those who don't give a rat @#$% about anyone else.
As for those who say some people are lazy, that is not true. Even if you bought plats and have uber stuff or you transfer stuffs to your alt and are playing the game fair. you still have to go thru the pain-numbing work of leveling your char. Just because you put a 30del, 30dmg weapon or you gave your spell caster stuff that raises their intel to above 200. They are still limited by their lvl and the level of their spells. Your not hitting for 100 or more pts of damage with weapon or spells that do only 7 pts of damage at lvl 1. This is why people were getting high lvl buffs on their twink to make them nearly invunerable. lots of people were upset when SoE changed it to lvl 45+.
So why do some people cheat. Because they are upset at what they see in this game. If you don't have a friend or family members already in game to kick start you are starting out with crap. It is hard pill to swallow when you are working hard in newbie zone and along comes a twink with uber buff, or a high lvl buffer, healer is pling his guild mate. In 30 mins or less they hit lvl 7. In an hour's time or so they come back and are lvl 12 to 15. While in that same time you are only lvl 2 or lvl 3 because your lovely 1hs that you got is slow and does low damage. I saw this a few times for myself while leveling alt to try out other race,class combo. While most of us accepted that this is EQ and decided to play anyway not everyone is the same. Soe decided to make it eaiser in recent times for newbie by having mobs that drop items that sell for 1plat, so in a few hours you could make 60 or more plat by level 5 or 6. But just like everything else in EQ when people found out how easy it was for newbies to make plat prices starting going up. And just like now, when people got wind that there was something funny going on, all of a sudden they jacked their prices on some things to double to cash in on the extra plat in EQ economy.
It funny, they point their little fingers at people and say they should have been banned for buying plats, buying items in website. Hacking EQ, using third party software to make money, increase their lvling abilities, etc, etc etc. Yet they still cashed in on all the dirty crap that was going on. Lots of vendor in bazaar have tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands plat extra because of this, yet they say these cheaters hurt the EQ economy, hurt the honest and hard working players. While Soe claims hundreds of char or accounts were deleted for life these so call honest people still lined their pockets and are still in EQ. Running to a bank where there is robbery taking place and selling said person stuffs doesn't make you less guilty. In this case, the robbers came to you and knowing there was something going on prices were jacked up anyways to take advantage of the extra rich economy. These are the same people who say powerleveling is okay and other forms of stuff is okay. Bottom line is that anything that gives you an advantage that other players don't have or can't afford is cheating. taking advantage of cheating even thou you didn't do it is cheating. Will Soe do anything NO!!!!! WHY first they are making good money on this game. If they weren't they wouldn't pay people to make new expansions if they thought there wasn't money in it. SECOND they won't change anything because players don't WANT ANYTHING CHANGED. SoE is not going to upset their paying customers, they need you to buy EQ2 and whatever else they have planned and they need your monthly money.
As for cheating. It is a fact of life. we're are stuck with it, so get used to it. Those that have have been banned from EQ have gone to others games to continue doing the same thing. It goes on in DAoC, Star wars, microsoft on-line games. I believe it goes on in at least 7 games on almost every server in those games.
Until the Gaming industry get serious about putting these people in jail, nothing is going to change. while you worked hard to level and save your plat to improve your char. In the end you will have nothing to show for your work except the personal satisfaction of having leveled your character honestly. others people don't feel the same way. They will do whatever it takes to get to level 65 in EQ or whatever levels there are in other games, and some are willing to pay hundreds of dollars or 1000+ dollars to have an internet store level their char to whatever lvl they are willing to spend. Depending on how rich your daddy is you can have a level 65 char delivered to you in about 2 weeks with full AA ponts, every tradeskill maxed out and the char personal skill maxed out like the testbuff char on test except max lvl.
So for those that say EQ or other online games are just GAMES. There is a serious darkside that is going on with online-gaming
so how
# Dec 17 2003 at 1:30 PM Rating: Decent
So exactly how did people cheat to get this? I heard it had to do with a mob you could turn 10 gold into and get 10pp back. If that is the case I don't feel those people should be banned, its SOE's fault for being stupid and leaving a quest like that in the game.

power leveling
# Dec 17 2003 at 12:53 PM Rating: Default
A message for all, direct from customer service...
Power leveling and buffs are not bannable actions, only the useage of expliots like those people that make lots of plats and what not are bannable, "power leveling has been part of the game ever since" and it is something that is bannable. Dont shot me I'm just the messanger direct from customer service rep. CSR Mike L told me this info. just my two cents...
RE: power leveling
# Dec 17 2003 at 2:01 PM Rating: Default
"power leveling has been part of the game ever since" and it is something that is *NOT* bannable...
cheating
# Dec 15 2003 at 7:50 PM Rating: Default
what about the people i see who say they were not cheating and have no idea why they were banned?? sound familur? Are we gonna get an EQ special police force to find the "cheaters"..who will throw the first stone.....getting scarey here peeps...(hope that someone does not accuse you of cheating) SOE thanks all of us for the "TIPS" ...Play your game, play it fair...have fun...stop worrying about what other peeps are doing. Smiley: yikes
cont...
# Dec 15 2003 at 7:30 PM Rating: Default
But there arent that many people around even in what used to be lag city ie POK....SOE wants people to play longer so they can make money plain and simple period...so they created the vendor mark up and hoped that it would be a long time before people started taking advatage of it...SOE started the hole then blames the players when the hole started to get too deep for them to make the profit they were making say four five years ago because the cheats made it so players didnt have to play as long and then sell their high level accounts on Ebay...now maybe I'm wrong but if SOE had thought of this I bet they wouldn't be so mad about it...maybe they should be the ones making even more money selling the plat and also making more restrictions on already high end items or even coming up with a plat cap for low end, mid range, and high end items? This has been a very long winded comment but i read all of the previous comments and noone brought up these points very well...But these are just my two cents never mind the masters I have in marketing and the associates in sociology... and I will admit to having done some things that might in ones opinion be considered cheating.. I befriended someone when i started out just to get the equipment off a necro he didnt want anymore.. and I still offer GG to anywhere a level 55 druid can go for profit.. I camp in the bizaar waiting for a under priced item then sell it for a profit...so delete me, ban me ,whatever.... nevermind me still doing things the hard way...killing stuff selling it for profit...I have restarted my necro twice because i didnt like the name she had....but still every three levels i plant my butt in POK get a clarity and work my skills up to were they should be for my current level and yes she is tweaked but i have earned the tweaked items she has through the above stated methods regardless of the inflated prices or being the only class that verant seems to nerf simply because he thinks necros are pure evil... because I have no choice but to pay the amount for what I want to have...I'm sorry alot of people are so focused on leveling fast but i always make sure i can handle a train if a noob pulls one to me...trains will never stop it is a fact and cannot be changed or nerfed we just have to grow up and deal with it and think to ourselves 'Gosh Darn NOOBS!!!" =)))
RE: cont...
# Dec 17 2003 at 12:10 PM Rating: Decent
I dont see anything wrong with camping in the bazaar for low price items. If i could play at work i would just monitor prices in bazaar all day in between customers and phone calls. You just spend more time at it then others and that makes people jealous. No one made them put the prices they are asking for the items and if they wanted to collect more plat for they should have charged more for it. As it has become easier to level i would think that fewer people are buying accounts. Most accounts dont sell unless they have uber gear that comes with the character. I dont see how cheaters were caught when online sites are still charging low prices for plat either. If they were truly caught those characters holding the plat in the bank would have been deleted. Causing prices to come back down in the game but dont forget the darkside of this is that when you do this a large amount of money will be removed from the economy. So many people buy plat that it could actually cause a scarcity of plat. The sites would still be buying plat off of players and the system would start all over and go down the same road again. The only people right now IMO that the current economy has hurt is the people who kill for plat and sell the loot to npc and the people who camp high end items and sell them in the bazaar and then turn around and cash in at the online sites. Granted lower item prices have not changed a whole lot but they still have changed. when you sell your item for an inflated price and want to buy an item at the old price that is greed. People who buy plat off of these sites are enjoying it because it is so cheap and has made the game more affordable.
This and That
# Dec 15 2003 at 6:50 PM Rating: Default
well,

I feel happy that justice has been served, if you cheat that you must be punished.

I wanted to put forward a few of my views about the economy of the game being an old skool player n` all. Firstly, you have to remember, EQ isnt fresh off the shelfs anymore, there are fewer and fewer noobs these days. What this leads to is lots of ppl with lots of high lvl characters who have lots of cash, cos of loot etc. SO as the average EQ player lvl increases, the economy is forced for warp a little, because there is an unlimited amount of plat and ppl`s lvl`s keep increasing.

My second point is that `why cheat?`

For exp? lol.. someone mentioned earlier about cheating to get to 65 in a week? That isnt a cheat, ppl have been doing that for ages.. i got a sk to 60 in like 3 days with a few friends and a full set of nice twinked armour.

The only reason i can see why ppl cheat, is to either resell the plat for $$$ or just for some `short lived` fun in bazaar twinking that lvl 13 ranger.. and how good are droppable items? wow CCoM.. fungi.. ornate.. lol.. if you want some REAL items (except FV server ofcourse) you have to raid (or even quest)..

So to sum up, if u wanna cheat, then cheat away and risk the ban/deletion of account, cos you aint gonna affect my DKP..

Lich 65th Evil Necromancer on Luclin Server =)









#REDACTED, Posted: Dec 17 2003 at 11:26 PM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) ohh your so cool, I wish I was as cool as you.
cont...
# Dec 15 2003 at 6:42 PM Rating: Default
And what about power leveling? What clearly defines a power level? Aren't we supposed to group with other people and take on mobs that we normally couldn't take on solo? I can understand if someone was a level five and was in Highkeep killing gobbies while a druid or the like kept him alive as being considered a power level.... but if there are groups of the same level people in there doing the same without the druid isnt that still a power level? This is supposed to be a RL simulator just based in a fantasy realm.... SOE has created this need to cheat ie through bugs and buying plat offline and whatnot throught their own greed ie vendors who buy stuff for a little and sell it back for double even triple....it's this markup for such menial items that has created the need to level fast so we can make more plat or inflate prices in the bizaar to exploit those that don't know the real value of an item....so of course people want to cheat and I apologize to any I offend with this next statement but...I don't want to sit in one area for hours even days just to gain one or two levels by myself because i need to med every three spells...I am not paying SOE every six months to do that and now that the level restricting LDoN has come out its made Norrath an even emptier place because now all the high level people are going there all the time so now that makes the low level people want to level even faster and get even better gear just so they can be included in a raid that only takes about thirty minutes...I am paying to interact with other epople from all over and have a great time doing it
RE: cont...
# Dec 17 2003 at 11:57 PM Rating: Default
Alright, are you what 3, 4, maybe 7 years old? You make no sense, go back to school, or atleast pass 3rd grade, then come back and post.
RE: cont...
# Dec 15 2003 at 11:04 PM Rating: Decent
you know you make absolutly no sense what so ever. If you don't want to pay and play by the rules only fear and stupidy keep you on the game move on. You know full well what is PLing as does everyone else in the game. I play by the rules and have no problem doing evrything you mentioned above. We all have a joice and we are in the game by joice are we not
has anyone even seen the one real bug sony has?
# Dec 15 2003 at 3:53 PM Rating: Decent
I'm sorry everyone..but i just don't understand any of this....the economy must be really bad in the EQ world....but i have to make this point clear....when i started playing i was alone and had no idea were to go..i did what everybody did..i hunted and sold stuff till i could get better stuff...then i realized something....when i sold something to an npc vendor ie a gem or some fine steel weapons or whatever... i saw that they would sell the same stuff i just sold them for sometimes double or even triple what i recieved for selling it in the first place...now it seeems to me that this is exactly what has driven the prices up in the bizaar....a) person sells stuff to vendor, b) vendor sells same stuff at higher price to make profit... now if the npc's are allowed to inflate prices like this why isn't everybody? they are and that is why everything is so out of proportion lately.... so how can a noob be expected to afford anything between levels 1-20?...they arent supposed to...not afford anything good at least hence they have to play longer ie months, years, decades at a time and make more money for soe.... sony shoved this game onto the market and now are mad because they can't keep up with all the bugs...you know what thats their fault...if they weren't ready to handle all of the cheats and bugs and hacks and what have you then they shouldn't have offered the game....so i congratulate all the cheaters but at the same time I would appreciate them not complaining when they get caught...and hopefully someday i can sell something to a vendor and have them sell it back to me for the same price =)))
Curious
# Dec 15 2003 at 1:57 PM Rating: Decent
Ok, so I admit I am a realatively new player and dont have a lvl 65 character, dont have an uber god tradeskill, dont even know most of the commands in the game (harmshield up for bashing)

But WTF is wrong some of these things. Powerlevling? Should the guy that gave my poor little lvl 8 Necro a shield and a better knife be banned, per the idea hell yes. Should the druid casting free Buffs in Gfay, hell yes. Should the Cleric rezzing newbies for free, hell yes. All the Clerics, Enchanters, Druids, Shamans and everyone else casting buffs in the POK, oh hell yes.

Should I for summoning peoples bodies for free, hell yes. Its all powerleveling, taking away those problems with getting experience that would otherwise be faced if you were going it alone. For example How many lvl 1 characters have 800 hp on there own. NONE, unless they get it from a Cleric and Temperance, per the definition, thats powerleveling.

Per the definition a shared bank is powerleveling, I have money in there that my new character can use that she obviously would never have made on her own, so am I powerlevling myself, hell yes.

Platinum duping, oh please, they dont kill you for counterfieting, they put you in jail. They shouldnt ban you, its thier money being lost. They should suspend you for 30 days (during which time you have to continue to pay) and then you come back.

I even saw someone suggest that transferring large amounts of money is a suggestion of cheating. OMFG people have you seen the bazaar, talk about money laundering. High my name is jimbob buy my 1p spell for 6million plat and then delete your character and come back with a new one and I will give your money back.

Or what about the poor fool that deletes his main to start all over and wants his friend to hang onto his plat and special items. Nope, thats cheating ban him.

Buying platinum online, is that cheating, you tell me. Is buying a character cheating, you tell me. To me, its no different than a bank charging you a fee for getting your own money out or a fee for buying a money order to give your money to someone else, you earned the money (plat) if you wanna sell it to someone its yours.
Someone had to earn the plat and since Sony obviously wont tell us how the plat was supposedly duplicated (if they fixed it why not) then I can only assume it was those people that bought platinum from somewhere. (BTW what if a friend just out and out gives me some plat, thats cheating right?)

The reality of it (at least for me) (harmshield back up since the inc hits are harder than I thought) is that IT IS A GAME Sony has forgotten that, the players have forgotten that, the EQ community has forgotten that.....

Sony good job at finding your flaw in your game. Players good job at helping them. Cheaters, good job at taking advantage of thier problem. Forum posters good job at bringing up questions that no one answers.

Now back to reality, Sony, when you ban people, you loose money (not only the players but the time it took you to do it and reply to the mis-accused). Players, you all loose out now because the people in the bazaar will simply price everything higher and no one can afford them.

Thanks everyone for reading my foolish rantings of someone who realizes its only a game.

And god forgive everyone one of you how ever snuck your piece ahead in a boardgame, or ever looked up a cheat online or who ever fibbed to your little brother about how to play the games as a little kid.


--Poor Necros make for alot of missing corpses--
I was Banned - an Update
# Dec 15 2003 at 12:34 PM Rating: Decent
Yes, I finally recieved some responses to my
banning protest emails.

Only problem is - they are all 'canned' responses,
with the exception of one.

First Response:

======================================================================
Subject: RE: Account banned
Content-Type: text/plain
Message-Id: <739EBE3EB103C54F93F94ACC2B843542032C81CE@MAIL-SD4.station.sony.com>
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Greetings Sir,

Thank you for emailing EQAccountStatus. According to our records you were
banned for transacting EQ items for cash. Unfortunately this is not
tolerated in EverQuest. As such your banning shall remain in place.

Thank you.

Regards,

EQAccountStatus
Sony Online Entertainment
eqaccountstatus@soe.sony.com
http://www.station.com
======================================================================

There were FOUR additional responses Identical to the one above.

Notice how it is 'canned' and not from any real person?


A Little while later I got this message:


=======================================================================

Greetings Sir;

Thank you for your email. According to our records your account has been banned for using a third party program to alter the game play of EverQuest, specifically macroing items to gain platinum. Please take a few minutes to review the EverQuest End User License Agreement which must be agreed to prior to entering EverQuest. For your convenience section six has been attached below:

6. We may terminate this Agreement (including your Software license and your Account) immediately and without notice if you breach this Agreement or repeatedly infringe any third party intellectual property rights, or if we are unable to verify or authenticate any information you provide to us, or upon gameplay, chat or any player activity whatsoever which is, in our sole discretion, inappropriate and/or in violation of the spirit of the Game as set forth in the player rules of conduct, which are posted at www.everquest.com. If we terminate this Agreement under these circumstances, you will lose access to your Account for the balance of any prepaid period without any refund. We may also terminate this Agreement if we decide, in our sole discretion, to discontinue offering the Game, in which case we may provide you with a prorated refund of any prepaid amounts.

Unfortunately the decision to leave your account banned remains unchanged. I wish you all the best in your future endeavors.


Sincerely,

Dustin Abbott
EQAccountStatus
Sony Online Entertainment
EQAccountStatus@soe.sony.com
============================================================================

So, is it because I used a macro?
or Purchased an Item?

Both?

Any proof or Evidence?
What about the other account that is used on the same computer?
That account has not been banned.






I have sent them reply with this:



Thank you for the reply.

I have a few issue's here:

1) I recieved several previous reply's that stated I
was banned for purchasing an item with Cash.

2) Your email stated I was banned for using a third
party program.


Please look into the details and
inform me of which situation actually resulted in
my account being banned.

If you can prove I purchased an item with cash,
fine, take the item away, give me a suspension,
lesson learned,
(I did NOT purchase an item with cash.)

I have never known, nor even considered using
a third party program to change my game play.


Please investigate further, either someone else has
used my account, or you have targeted the wrong
account, I have always enjoyed playing EQ and have
never had the desire or need to 'cheat'.



signature.
RE: I was Banned - an Update
# Feb 10 2004 at 3:37 PM Rating: Default
So, is it because I used a macro?
or Purchased an Item?

Both?

Any proof or Evidence?
------------------------------------------------

Well yea theres evidence you just said you used a macro and purchased an item. So if you cheated I say ... Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha loser.
And if you didnt... sorry about your luck pal.
RE: I was Banned - an Update
# Dec 15 2003 at 11:19 PM Rating: Default
Yes and I can imagine just about anyone that was banned can a will be using the same argument lots of luck be more chosy who uses you computer LOL,
Law
# Dec 15 2003 at 9:02 AM Rating: Default
with the effect the plat dupe had on the EQ economy, you now know why counterfiting carries a greater penalty than murder in many places. it doesn't just effect a few people, it impacted across all EQ servers.
I'm Sorry
# Dec 14 2003 at 9:42 PM Rating: Default
I just want to say that i am very sorry for all of teh people who cheat... you don't get any real,fun game exp...what is the use of getting to lvl 65 in 1 week... you change EQ from a role-playing game to a strangely,very real life game where everyone is always cheating and ruining everyone else's game exp.... i don't see the point of cheating. again i am very,very soryy for the cheaters for that reason an di also feel very sorry for all the people that have to come in contact with them or have to even just talk to them... thanks for listening good luck, have fun, and don't die.



FROGLOKS RULE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE: I'm Sorry
# Dec 16 2003 at 3:23 AM Rating: Decent
Frogloks SUCK
>:[]
# Dec 14 2003 at 1:35 AM Rating: Default
concise! unlike the rest of those who must think that what they say is the MOST important thing in the world!!!

its a game! yes! its not yours! you didnt make it, yet you play it... you dont like it, leave and go play D2.

you dont like that you cant cheat, write to former president Bill Clinton. maybe he will hear your whining and do something for you.

jealous of the fact that some people work hard for their plat and are in uber guilds getting the "UBER LOOTS", well suck it up, look up some quests to do and start from there.

the "liberal" attitudes are going to put caps on xp, soloing(its already been done), prices to charge for items you deserved on hard raids, the items you create from your chars hard earned skill points... i could go on.

you cant have 65 in a day and if you do, then you put the rest of us veterans of the game at risk with your "noobish" actions.

so very sorry for you new players who get to 65 in a week or less, that the real 65ers know how the game is played and how the real plat is earned.

you wanna bust folks for something... bust the ones who try to sell their accounts in the bazaar. thats just plain wrong. i dont need the spam of some rip off artist clogging my screen.
Shades of Gray
# Dec 13 2003 at 9:22 PM Rating: Default
If the shades of Gray run from almost BLACK[/b to almost [b]WHITEWHITE Then.... Using a 3rd party HackPrg to exploit Verant/Sony Proprietary Code... is Black But If I throw darts at lunch with you for your Copper hammer of Striking against my Orb of forgotten Magic.... and win.. and YOU and I meet in the POK to settle the bet... That's on th far side of GRAY and I hope like Hell that this isn't what has happened to earn someone a BAN! BTW it's a game... it's Sony's job to make it work... not play cops and robbers. It's our job to explore.... exploit the bugs and have a ball... and if you don't use reason and tact.... Well,
Quote:
We're in their world now!
Platinum and prices
# Dec 13 2003 at 8:05 PM Rating: Decent
*
105 posts
This explains the doubling and sometimes tripling prices for items in the bazaar. If the money supply is high in any economy, you run the risk of inflation. Sony has thought up a few ways to take platinum out of the game over the years to prevent such inflation. Tradeskill componants from vendors, quests involving handing money to NPCs, and horses/lizards come to mind.

Banning cheaters and their duped platinum is a necessary step to normalize the market. Keep your eyes peeled for more ways to spend (not trade) platinum too. The changes to melee discaplines could incorporate spending chunks of plat for tomes. I'd personally like to see NPC buff merchants implemented. No more waiting around for someone to cast kei.
#Anonymous, Posted: Dec 13 2003 at 5:29 PM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) I play EQOA, i play on Ferrans Hope for ps2 and what about when someone ask you can i see your shield or wep and takes off with it...is there anything i can do to get it back!! Yes i let him see it, then he took off with my shield, it was expensive and a gift...am i screwed and chalk it up as a loss or can u help??? Elvatoloco is the name of character who stole my shield, please help!!
RE: Xango
# Dec 15 2003 at 11:28 PM Rating: Default
Your loss he could have looked at it in the trade window, we all live and learn:=(
What is Cheating?
# Dec 13 2003 at 5:26 AM Rating: Default
Does anyone know exactly what is considered cheating by Sony? The way they describe it seems pretty vague. I would think they should specify exactly what is considered a bug or an exploit in detail. Why can’t they go into detail if they have corrected the bug or the exploit? I for one would like to know. Especially if it means potentially getting banned for life.

Now obviously finding a way to duplicate platinum would be an exploit. What else specifically?

Is all power leveling cheating? How about farming trade skill or other items to sell in the Bazaar? I would think not. After all NO DROP items can be sold or traded and casting most high level spells on lower level characters is allowed. The person casting that high level spell on a lower level character had to acquire their level and spell. The person selling you that leather padding for 25pp had to make the padding or buy it from someone who did. Also, I would think anything that can be traded or sold, should be able to be sold for any price the buyer and seller agree on. If the buyer overpays for something, I would think that is his loss. He can do his homework just as the seller has. Or vice versa.

Now as far as buying or selling Plat or items for real money. That is a different story. This is clearly in the EULA if you read it. So if you choose to do this, you run the risk of getting caught. I personally have not done this. That being said however, I think this is somewhat of an unfair rule in the User Agreement. As long as the Plat or item that was being bought or sold was earned legitimately. Meaning originally it was acquired by someone who spent their time and effort to get it. Then I think we should be able to buy or sell that item for real money if we so wished. After all Sony does not own our time and effort. Trading or even giving away Plat or an item that isn’t NO DROP to someone else is legal in the game. Whether or not we received something for it Offline, should be none of Sony’s concern. After all this is not making them any less rich than they are now. Some would say this would change the economy of EQ. Maybe it would maybe it wouldn’t. Everything we pay Plat for impacts the economy. As long as the Plat is earned by someone legitimately, the game economy shouldn't be negatively affected.

As far as banning the cheaters I think the punishments may have been a little harsh. Some people should probably have gotten suspensions or warning rather than exile. They should have focused on the prime offenders. The people who created the Duplication Cheat, and banned them. Others who may have made a poor judgment or mistake by using the Cheat should have received a lesser punishment.

I realize I do not own EQ or make the decisions. Sony does. However, in a lot of ways this is as much our game as it is theirs. We are the ones that buy the software, pay the monthly fee, put in the long hours to make the game what it is. If it wasn’t for us the CUSTOMER, this game we love so much would have only been a flash in the pan, reduced to the $10 software bin at the local computer store.

Please understand this is all my humble opinion. I realize that some people may completely disagree, while others may feel the same way I do. I would like to hear from both sides. This is the first topic that I felt strongly enough to post to and have enjoyed reading all the threads.

Thanks

RE: What is Cheating?
# Dec 13 2003 at 9:01 AM Rating: Decent
“Others who may have made a poor judgment or mistake by using the Cheat should have received a lesser punishment.”

I think this game is some what like real life. You know when you are doing wrong (unless you are socially challenged) to justify it by saying it is only a little wrong is just not right. This sort of mirrors some of the faults in RL. It is ok to kill someone if I didn’t mean too, does this really make difference to the person killed. As we are beginning to see by some of the post here cheating does affects everyone, even those that are innocent because “they may have made a poor judgment or mistake” come on.

“The way they describe it seems pretty vague. I would think they should specify exactly what is considered a bug or an exploit in detail.”

Do you have any idea how big the EULA would have to be to accomplish this? This could be the start of a whole new class in the game called lawyers ;-).You are supposed to have attained a certain age by the time you play this game. If you have met this requirement you should now know the difference between right and wrong. I personally do not seem to have a problem in this area. When something in the game does not seem right I usually send a petion and the issue is cleared up for me shortly. If the GM or guide say bug or exploit I am content to live with that. I personally find exploits and bug very easy to spot.

“Whether or not we received something for it Offline, should be none of Sony’s concern.”

What does the EULA say about this? You agree with this by pressing accept. Why try to justify doing it after that seem overly simple to me. Rules are rules if you do not agree with them don’t press accept. You can not generally have you cake and eat it to.

I get so tired of people in groups bragging about being uber player when at level 20 they are sporting level 50+ gear full sets. As far as I am concerned this take away from the whole experience. I would like to see all gear with a level restriction. If this were so than this whole issue would not have likely happened. I so enjoyed going to the newbie server when it went live because there for a while people were geared according to their level. I can remember the days when pre 46 level groups were refusing to take casters if they did not have KEI. I was so happy to see the level restriction on KEI. All forms of “cheats” do affect others even when they play by the rules, no matter how you try to justify them.



Edited, Sat Dec 13 09:02:35 2003
RE: What is Cheating?
# Dec 13 2003 at 5:22 PM Rating: Decent

"It is ok to kill someone if I didn’t mean too, does this really make difference to the person killed."

What? How can you even start to compare killing someone to what these people did? The cheaters that actually created the cheat I agree should have been banned. But the hundreds that may have only took part; I just believe banishment is a little harsh. I never said they were innocent. Suspend them for six months to a year. If they get caught again then send them into exile. I am not going to argue whether or not this is Sony's right. But regardless these people didn't completely ruin the game, it still goes on, and some would agree is better than ever. These people that were banned are still Sony's customers who spent their hard earned money to play the game. Even RL people get a second chance. We wouldn't throw someone in jail for the rest of their lives for stealing a car, and we shouldn't. Punishment needs to fit the crime, and in some of the cases here, I don't think it does.

"Do you have any idea how big the EULA would have to be to accomplish this? This could be the start of a whole new class in the game called lawyers ;-).You are supposed to have attained a certain age by the time you play this game."

The EULA should be as long as it needs to be. If this is a legal document it should be as detailed as possible, so there is no confusion. However, it doesn't necessarily even have to be in the EULA. Sony can list exploits or bugs on the website. Since some of the bugs and exploits are eventually fixed, there would be no need to list every last bug or exploit that ever existed. Also, from reading some of these posts, seems like people were banned without even an explanation. That is not right. They may well know what they did, but a few may not have, and an explanation is warranted.

Being as I am over the age of five, can read and write, and walk and chew gum at the same time. I like to think I know right from wrong. I don't believe I use bugs and exploits. Can I be sure Sony shares my common sense? I hope so, but who knows. When we are talking about laws and rules, they are not always that simple. That is why they should (and usually are) be spelled out. Even an educated person can unknowingly break a law.

"What does the EULA say about this? You agree with this by pressing accept."

I know exactly what it says I have read it many times. What I am saying is I don't think it should be in there. Will I still play the game? Yes. Will I follow this rule? Yes, I have no choice. Should I be able to think this rule should not be in the EULA? Yes. Just as in RL you can follow a law but you can still speak out against it.


"All forms of “cheats” do affect others even when they play by the rules, no matter how you try to justify them."

I always thought when you played by the rules that you weren't cheating? Guess not huh? Maybe you should follow your own advice from above... "Rules are rules if you do not agree with them don’t"... Play. If Sony didn't want people to twink their alt characters why the shared bank? The shared bank is so you can share plat and items between your characters, what did you expect would happen? If Sony didn't want people casting high level spells on lower level characters then why aren't there even more restrictions? Probably because a majority of the people don't want the restrictions and do want the shared bank. It will never be a level playing field. Obviously Sony is allowing this by not changing the game. The average player will always do what he can to make his character as formidable as possible, within the rules. If he is not breaking those rules, then he is not cheating.

Looks like you disagree with rules in the game as well. We are in the same boat just on separate issues.

Thanks for the reply.
Heh I musta missed somethin'
# Dec 13 2003 at 4:19 AM Rating: Default
I only ever have a problem with cheating when it affects someone elses playing. If the guy next to me wants to PL, I say let him. Won't affect my game. If the guy next to me wants to twink his toon, he should go right ahead. Won't affect my game. But if the guy next to me makes it so I can't afford so and so item cause he manipulated the game to raise the prices for said item on the market, well, he should be beheaded. Heh. Go play FFXI you don't hear about this garbage there ^_^

Poll: Were you Banned? Have you received a Response?
# Dec 12 2003 at 12:01 PM Rating: Decent
Please only reply if you
were banned during the 'sweep' of December 6th, 7th, and 8th.

And, if so,

Have you gotten a response from
eqaccountstatus@soe.sony.com?

RE: Poll: Were you Banned? Have you received a Response?
# Dec 13 2003 at 4:14 PM Rating: Default
yup i was banned havent a clue why either , dont even know how i cheated , in any case no i havent received an email yet


Former 65th level transcendant of the seventh hammer
RE: Poll: Were you Banned? Have you received a Response?
# Dec 13 2003 at 1:31 PM Rating: Default
I was not banned, but two RL friends of mine were suspended during the sweep. I wasn't really playing at all that week, so meh. One friend was caught during a LDON adventure or something, and the GM said he would be suspended, but not banned, and other friend just got suspended like two nights ago or something, only one of them got an email
RE: Poll: Were you Banned? Have you received a Response?
# Dec 13 2003 at 1:31 PM Rating: Default
I was not banned, but two RL friends of mine were suspended during the sweep. I wasn't really playing at all that week, so meh. One friend was caught during a LDON adventure or something, and the GM said he would be suspended, but not banned, and other friend just got suspended like two nights ago or something, only one of them got an email
RE: Poll: Were you Banned? Have you received a Response?
# Dec 12 2003 at 12:30 PM Rating: Decent
Yup

no response, nothing.
Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 12 2003 at 8:44 AM Rating: Good
Wow...took alot of time to read all those posts...one thing I haven't noticed anyone point out...the real cause of those higher prices in bazaar...GREED. These items that have gone thru the roof on price aren't being sold by hackers/coin dupers...they are being sold by the same people who always sell them. They get wind of an exploit and immediately start raising their prices in hopes of garnering more money from whoever will pay. Kinda like in the real world, the moment even the hint of raising minimum wage is brought up, check the price of your next cheeseburger...
Sure Joe Blow could go ahead and sell his Fungi Tunic for let's say, the going rate of 60k. But Joe thinks there're people out there who will pay him 120k for it, so he puts that price on it and, low and behold, some idjit buys it! Joe is happy...he tells all his friends his good fortune and increases the prices on nearly everything else he is selling. This affects the bazaar scanners who don't have much idea what price they should put on their items, but see Joe asking a fortune for his, so they figure what's good for Joe is good for them and WHALLAH! There go those bazaar prices thru the roof. What will bring the prices down? Not buying Joe's frikkin Fungi at 120k...or any of the other crazily inflated things out there right now. If you have lots of legitimately earned money atm and are concerned with the prices now, the best thing you can do is sit on your money until the merchants get the idea that their stuff won't sell at those prices. This could take weeks or even months of patience on your part tho, depending on how much "fake" or duplicated platinum has infected the various servers, and whether or not it has been stopped. Just keep in mind it's almost as much the fault of the greedy merchants trying to suck up as much plat as they can get their grubby little hands on as it is the @#$/! who have found a way to hack our beloved game. Don't feed the current crisis by panicking and blowing all your hard earned dough...
RE: Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 12 2003 at 11:26 AM Rating: Default
I get such a kick out all this fuss about the prices in the bazaar. The ones doing all the complaining are usually the ones that do not want to put the effort into getting their levels. They want to rush up the EXP ladder clad in gear they have not earned or deserve. If everyone out there were to earn their gear than there would be no economy to ***** about. The only reason you would be purchasing gear is you are either to low a level to get it legit or you are too lazy to go out and earn it. It is people like you who dive this economy and it is people like me who have put in the time and effort that benefits this is life. I know it sucks from you r side but is great from mine. Your reference to the cheese burger is so true, if the cost of producing it goes up than the end price has to go up (try running a business) very simple math. Life is made up of people (merchants) who make money and people who will always be only consumers (you) lmao.
RE: Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 13 2003 at 10:45 AM Rating: Excellent
***
3,705 posts
Can't help but disagree with your intepretation of "earn".

My main (who is 65 btw, and has 24 aa) bought a lot of his gear in the bazaar. However, I earned the plat to do so. I didn't buy it online, or bum it from friends. I worked my smithing up to 250, and collected ingredients, made heraldic armor, and hurricane plate, and even a few pieces of livestone. I patiently sold this stuff, and when I had enough cash, and items like Ornate greaves, mold came up for sale, I bought them. Sure I could quit the guild I'm in, go join some raid guild, and get better gear by raiding. However, I LIKE my guild, and don't WANT to raid constantly.

Do I feel that I have EARNED my gear. You bet I do. Sure I feel more pride in my shawl, then I do in my purchased items, since I did the quest myself, but I still earned the other stuff. Just in a different way that you "earned" your gear by raiding.
RE: Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 13 2003 at 4:12 PM Rating: Decent
I was not referring to people who earn their equipment such as you did. What does bug me is people at 20 tweaked with level 50+ gear than spend the majority of their play time bragging how ubber they are, when without that gear they would be squat. It takes about 2 minutes into a group activity when they prove the only thing uber about them is their gear. I would like to see every piece of gear in the game with a lvl restriction.
RE: Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 14 2003 at 8:38 PM Rating: Default
Everything with a level restriction? Why not make everything no drop. We can even have character restrictions on servers limiting them to 1 toon per server (SWG). This kind of thinking is lame. There are better answers out there.
RE: Greed has a large part to play in this
# Dec 16 2003 at 5:15 PM Rating: Decent
Limiting items to a DEGREE is fine and helps stop the below. I play on Sullon and my highest char is at 39. I also have an alt who is 13, I PKed someone with this alt who turned white as he killed a mob. Although I have a more powerful char who could kill some giants in Rath and earn some cash to buy this alt some relativley great gear I play so my new char earns his money sepratly. The other char had great armor - could bearly hit him, he didn't have a clue how to use his char or fight, skills can't have been trained up either. NO WAY should I have one the fight due to his guys armor and he was obviously new to the game. This is what cheating and power-leveling causes. Power-leveling, although annoying, I can cope with but hacking the game is wrong. Ban those who created the hacks or sell/buy on ebay and suspend and fine (game money, items and xp) the people who used the hacks.

IF YOU HACK THE GAME YOU ARE NOT PLAYING IT
PLing
# Dec 12 2003 at 8:02 AM Rating: Decent
What is this about grouping PLing in with all the hacking/p duping and cheating? Pling is a natural part of the game. I made my Druid just for that. He is level 60 now and all he does is PL and port family around. We have GM crafters in all the skills are we cheaters because we make gear for our newbie players and Pl them to level 20 and send them on their way? If that is true then every one of you that pays for KEI and then goes and group Kills a red you could not solo are cheating too, lets not stop there, GM crafters that combine for other players are cheating and so on. It is part of the game to get to a level where you can do youself or someone else some good. If I want to get a Druid to level 60 so he can PL my Monk to level 40 then I can and will. If you want to put the effort and time into it then you deserve the same benefits. Nuff said...
RE: PLing
# Dec 13 2003 at 10:13 AM Rating: Default
Considering PLing, I think to have an example...
I was leveling my Enchanter in Paludal last month, yes, I confess, he is a little twink, equipped with stuff my main collected or bought at the bazaar and spells finanzed from the pockets of my main. Now at the same time an lvl 11 ogre warrior was pl´ed there - we were at camp 1, fighting and killing bandits, when the ogre and his anonym spellslinger-buddy stormed the scene. Suddenly each and every bandit froze and turned towards the caster just to be slaughtered by the warrior without a chance.
And the answer to our complaints (and those of the group on the lake-side) why they just had to clean ´our´ camp - well they told us to shut up and leave if we couldn´t take it...
So, clearly I don´t happen to have much love for pling and pl´ed chars.
Yesterday while visiting the Maiden´s Eye with my main to solo some Toilers for dinner, I met the warrior again, now level 54 and as incompetent as possible, creating trains in a row when pulling, training other chars in the zone while running to the zone out, losing aggro etc. The group he was in trickled away one by one over the course of two hours.
Well, on the other hand I got most of the trains and managed to stop them in their tracks, getting some money and even experience points, but had one of those trains hit me cold, for example just after entering ME, well...
RE: PLing
# Dec 13 2003 at 4:28 PM Rating: Default
The majority of the time the PL'er have no respect for the time a legit palyer puts in to gain exp. Thus they don't care if they cause a train that kills 2 or 3 player, or bust into a camp a ***** up a spawn cycle that has taken an hour to set up and possibly a death(sollo lots). They just have no respect for what they didn't earn.
RE: PLing
# Dec 12 2003 at 6:45 PM Rating: Default
While PLing isn't breaking the rules, it does take away from the spirit of the game. I don't believe in PLing except in a couple of cases, and PLing a main is certainly detrimental to the game as a whole, since the player won't learn how to properly play his role, and that will ***** him up later. I've had the misfortune to group with people like that (like a 33rd level ranger who didn't know he had forage, taunt, or even kick! Or the idiot 40th level warrior who didn't understand how to /assist and kept breaking my mez, even though I was announcing it in group speak!)
I love playing the game, and can't understand how someone would want to PL because you miss out on all the fun. After playing my main, I love pulling up one of my alts and get a level or 2 soloing, or go back to my favorite zones my main no longer gets xp in. Just as in real life, the journey is much more important than the destination. I have winced many times when exploring anew zone and finding neat camps, only to realise I am now too high of level for them, and I missed out on them. That's why I have alts, tho, so I can explore every zone at the proper level it was designed for.
The only valid reasons for PLing IMHO, is to get an alt with different tradeskills, etc (I created a gnome enchanter so I could get tinkering and jewelry skills, and a shaman to imbue amber for my smith; I don't like to play those classes much) or if your group of friends has out-levelled you and you need to catch up so you can group with them again. Of course, then it should be your friends PLing you. -P
Tanz Sixfingers
50 Bard on Terris-Thule
Raid Officer for One Fellowship guild
RE: PLing
# Dec 13 2003 at 3:03 PM Rating: Default
I just want to add that I totally agree! I have my main and various alts of different levels. It is SUCH a pain in a **** to play an alt in a group with a player who has NO CLUE what his class is capable of because they were PLed. In the end, I usually end up trying to help that person learn his class if it is one of my higher level characters. OMG, I came to escape not teach someone else how to play a class that I knew ages ago. :)
RE: PLing
# Dec 12 2003 at 4:58 PM Rating: Default
I don't think pling was mentioned in there. It says "extremely fast leveling without inside help" meaning an experience exploit from soloing an easy monster with lots of experience ;-) I myself play a druid,lvl 54 on Luclin,and if they ban those who plvl,then my god,you know how many people would leave the game over some stupid thing like pling.

Sedar Bloodsaber
54 Wanderer
<Dragon Spawn>
Luclin Server
[Half Elf] Sedar [54 Wanderer]<Dragon Spawn> LFG
#REDACTED, Posted: Dec 12 2003 at 2:41 AM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) Duping plat,running macrobots,exploiting bugs,cheating the system ,PLing,ruining the EQ economy.I have seen this on every website about EQ lately.The way I see it,more effort should be done by Sony to fix there software and quit blaming the players for exploiting them.I myself do not exploit bugs,but have reported several of them,and as of today have never recieved a simple thanks from the EQ team for trying to help them.I usually get the same response when petitioning a GM when I lose XP or items due to lag or other problems with there game.I think banning players for finding and exploiting bugs is wrong.Maybe they should hire these exploiters to find the other countless problems with there software.
RE: Blah Blah Blah
# Dec 13 2003 at 10:53 AM Rating: Good
***
3,705 posts
Yeah, thats like saying "you should have had better locks on your doors, then nobody would have stolen your Stereo."

Same argument. Still just an excuse.

The cheaters still suck, regardless of what Sony could do differently to stop them. Bottom line is, there is a TON of code in the game, with multiple programmers, and often a change made by one, creates a problem they are unaware of. If you find the bug, report it, so it can be fixed, don't exploit it to ruin the game for everyone else.

If I challenge you to a game of chess, and rearrange pieces every time you look away from the board, did I win anything when I checkmate you? If I have to cheat to win, why bother to play.
RE: Blah Blah Blah
# Dec 16 2003 at 2:37 AM Rating: Default
If someone stole my stereo because I had a crappy lock on my door, I would get a better lock.

If you build a highrise and realize after 2 or 3 floors that you have a bad foundation,you do not continue to add floors to it until the foundation is repaired.
I myself have reported bugs in the game and often check to see if they have been fixed,most of them have not,yet they have no problem trying to shove the latest expansion down my throat everytime I log in.
I despise the cheaters as much as the next guy,but I blame Sony for spending too much time adding expansions and not enough time fixing what they already have.From my experience these bugs usually show up right after a new expansion is released.
If you travel through all of the zones you will discover that a lot of the zones have no players in them at all.Instead of adding new zones,they could add content to the underpopulated zones and attract players back to them.
If WalMart shipped a product to all of it's stores and due to a computer glitch the product was selling for half price and the problem went on for a week,would the people that took advantage of this price glitch be banned from Walmart forever.Of course not,Walmart would fix the glitch and go on with business as usual.The same applies to the ones exploiting bugs in the game,don't waste time trying to track the exploiters,fix the bugs.
Hacker's on the other hand fall into a different category,if they are hacking into Sony's servers they are in violation of Federal and International laws and should be punished accordingly.
Sigh
# Dec 11 2003 at 10:18 PM Rating: Good
Whether Sony has done a proper job of creating and running Everquest is not what this is about. Anyone supporting cheating by using how Sony has run the game as an excuse is as bad as a cheater himself. There is nothing right about cheating in any multiplayer game, but it is an especially heinous crime in a game like Everquest where thousands of players exist in a persistent world where game balance is paramount.
« Previous 1 2 3
Post Comment

Free account required to post

You must log in or create an account to post messages.