TherealLogros wrote:
I agree in regards of Chronicle but I think Cloverfield greatly benefited from the "first person" angle. The shots when they are just between the monsters toes and tanks, jeeps and whatnot are nuking the **** out of it are incredible.
To be fair, Cloverfield stretched the medium a bit. There were shots in there that no sane person would have been taking (or would be highly unlikely to have been framed so well given the events going on at the time). It was well done, but I still had that "why bother" feeling. If they'd not even tried to make it into a found film thing, they could have really done a great job visually. Instead they pushed it to the point where it wasn't really believable as found film, but still wasn't as good as it would have been if they'd just filmed it normally.
For me personally, I'd much rather just deal with the suspension of disbelief to allow for the imaginary camera that's showing me what's happening, from many angles, with good framing and editing, than deal with the pinhole view of events that you get with the whole found film format. I just don't see enough value in it. YMMV of course.
Edited, Jan 7th 2015 5:49pm by gbaji