I think the point of the thread is "what if you could duel, who would be best". But you also have a point in that, we cant really be certain who would beat whom, unless the choice to duel/pvp is allowed ( PLEASE MAKE PVP SERVERS!! ). Who knows what strategies will develop, or how classes can match up. Exploits might be discovered that may/may not exist during a PvE encounter.
Not trying to diss anyone, although I think this is a very interesting topic.
Anyone who have any information regarding the possibility of PvP element being introduced to eq2, please share wit us.